Skip to content

Education and the Workforce: What the Early Days of Online Learning Still Teach

Blackboard founder Stephen Gilfus on the gap between what students learn and what employers need, and how online learning began with a page for every course.

Listen to this articleRead by an AI voice
Education and the workforce a college graduate in cap and gown carrying a diploma walks from a university hallway into a busy modern workplace

Education and the workforce have drifted apart. Blackboard founder Stephen Gilfus on that gap, how online learning began and what colleges asked for next.

Stephen Gilfus, a Founder of Blackboard and CEO of Gilfus Education Group4 min 34 sedCircuit on Vimeo

Education and the workforce have drifted apart, and Blackboard founder Stephen Gilfus sees the gap as something colleges and employers will have to build their way across. At the 2014 ASU GSV Summit, he told edCircuit where the gap comes from, how online learning began and what colleges are asking for now.

His view carries the weight of someone who helped build the systems most colleges now run their courses on. It also reaches past technology. The question he keeps returning to is what a student can do at the end of a course, and whether anyone outside the college can see it.

Why are education and the workforce out of step?

Colleges put a great deal of effort into the learning experience they offer students. Employers put a great deal of effort into finding people who can do the work in front of them. Between the two, Gilfus says, there is “a lack of connective tissue.” A student can finish a strong program and still arrive at a job that asks for something the program never set out to teach.

The gap is not for lack of good intentions on either side. Higher education organizes learning around courses, credits and degrees. Employers organize work around tasks, roles and results. Each side measures progress in its own terms, and those terms rarely line up. A transcript records which courses a student passed. It says much less about what the student learned to do.

Employers are saying much the same thing. In a Gallup survey of 623 business leaders for Lumina Foundation, released in February, just over a third agreed that colleges are graduating students with the skills and competencies their businesses need. About a third disagreed, and the rest were neutral.

The same leaders care more about what a candidate can do than where the candidate studied. Lumina’s report on the poll found that business leaders weigh a job candidate’s knowledge and skills far more heavily than the school they attended or their college major. That is the pressure Gilfus describes when he points to the attention employers are now paying to credentials, and it is the reason shorter, skills-focused programs such as online certificates are drawing interest from working adults.

Learning that moves into the workplace

The workplace is also becoming a place where people learn. More people already in jobs want to keep building their education where they work, through the systems their employers run, instead of leaving to go back to school. For a working adult with a family and a mortgage, a course that fits into the workday is often the only course that fits at all.

That shift puts similar technology on both sides of the line. Colleges run course platforms to deliver classes. Companies run training platforms to build skills on the job. Both handle content, communication and records of progress, but they grew up separately, with different ideas of what counts as completing something. A certificate earned at work and a course completed at a college can describe overlapping skills without either one recognizing the other.

Gilfus expects closing the gap to take the next four to five years, and he does not think shared technology alone will do it. Common platforms can move content and records between a campus and a company. Colleges and employers will also need common teaching approaches, with courses on both sides designed around what the workforce needs people to be able to do, so that learning in one place counts in the other.

How did online learning begin?

The way online learning started shows how a large change can grow out of a small, practical one. Today the conversation centers on pedagogy, the student experience, student interaction, engagement and retention, and on how online tools connect to the physical campus. Blackboard’s beginning, as Gilfus tells it, was far simpler than that.

Around 1997, colleges were trying to get onto the web, and putting up a page for every instructor would have been costly. Each page had to be designed, built and posted, and a campus might have thousands of courses. Few faculty members had the time or the skills to build their own, and few institutions had the staff to build them all.

Blackboard’s first system gave an institution a templated way to create thousands of faculty web pages at once, each with room for course content and a few basic communication tools. An instructor could post a syllabus, share readings and reach students without writing a line of code. For the college, a project that would have been too expensive one instructor at a time became affordable across the whole campus.

The educational purpose came after the pages existed. Once courses were online, colleges began working out how faculty and students should use those sites, and how the communication tools could support teaching. Discussion, assignments and feedback moved onto the same pages, and the tools grew with that use.

Few people now think of these systems as websites, or even as course websites. They have become online learning environments, built around the experiences, interactions and outcomes students need on the way to a degree. The same history explains why so much of today’s education technology conversation is about outcomes: the tools were built first, and the question of what they should accomplish followed.

Lining courses up with careers

That focus on outcomes leads back to the workforce. Through the Gilfus Education Group, colleges are asking for help with curriculum alignment and course alignment: tying each course to clear objectives and outcomes, and then tying those outcomes to the work students are preparing for.

The work starts with the course, the smallest unit a college controls. A course that states what a student should be able to do when it ends can be measured against that promise, and those promises can be lined up across a program. When the outcomes of a program match the skills an employer is hiring for, a student has a clearer path, and an employer has a clearer reason to trust the degree.

The degree still sets the limits. A college has to meet its degree requirements, so alignment works inside that structure rather than replacing it. The aim is to give students a path from their courses to a career while they complete the degree they enrolled for. Colleges with strong ties to employers, including those offering career and technical education, have long worked this way. Gilfus sees more institutions asking how to apply the same thinking across their programs.

The difference one teacher makes

For all the attention on systems, Gilfus credits individual attention with much of what a student gains. Learners who work one-on-one with an instructor outside the classroom can progress 25 to 30 percent faster, a figure he cites from a recent conversation with a friend.

His own example comes from Cornell, where his undergraduate degree focused on entrepreneurship, personal enterprise and building businesses. Two mentors helped him there, and one above all: Professor Deborah Streeter, who guided him and served as a sounding board for everything he was working on. Computers were his hobby at the time, and the hobby became his career.

It is a useful reminder from someone whose company helped put courses online at scale. Technology can carry a course to thousands of students. The difference for any one of them still often comes down to a teacher who makes time to listen.

More conversations with founders and investors are collected in EdTech Entrepreneurs.

Stephen Gilfus is a co-founder of Blackboard and president and CEO of the Gilfus Education Group.

Subscribe to edCircuit to stay up to date on all of our shows, podcasts, news, and thought leadership articles.

More on EdTech Entrepreneurs

Share

More from edCircuit

Subscribe to edCircuit

Get the latest research, ideas, and stories delivered to your inbox.

Cancel