Skip to content

Technology in the Classroom Is Not Enough: Building a Culture of Expectation

Anthony Salcito, Microsoft's vice president of worldwide education, explains why more technology in the classroom has rarely changed schools, what Philadelphia's School of the Future set out to prove, and why teachers matter more as learning moves beyond the school.

Listen to this articleRead by an AI voice
A teacher talks with three students working on paper at a table while closed laptops sit on a shelf technology in the classroom is not enough

Anthony Salcito, VP of Education, Microsoft Worldwide6 min 1 sedCircuit on Vimeo

Putting more technology in the classroom is not enough to change how students learn, in the view of Anthony Salcito, Microsoft’s vice president of worldwide education, and the company’s education work starts from that idea. At the 2014 ASU GSV Summit in Scottsdale, Arizona, he told edCircuit how the company approaches schools, what the School of the Future in Philadelphia set out to prove, why so much classroom technology has gone unused, how teachers fit into the change and whether schools around the world are moving fast enough.

Salcito speaks from years of work with schools in many countries, and from his own part in starting one in Philadelphia. His case is that the hardest part of changing a school is not the equipment. It is what students expect of themselves when they walk in the door, and what teachers are trusted to do once they are inside.

What is Microsoft doing in education?

Microsoft is best known for its software, and many people would expect its work in schools to be about putting that software in front of students. Salcito describes a long-standing commitment to improving education around the world, one that goes back to the company’s founder, Bill Gates, and his passion for the subject.

The company’s approach, he says, is a little different from what people assume. It is not about the technology. It is about thinking about learning as a whole: how to transform it, how to support teachers and school leaders, and how to apply technology thoughtfully to the problems schools actually have.

The aim runs in that order. Education technology comes in where it can help inspire students, deliver new outcomes and support new ways of teaching, the new pedagogies that change how students and teachers work together.

What did the School of the Future set out to do?

The School of the Future in Philadelphia was Microsoft’s first innovative school, and Salcito was personally involved in starting the project. The school opened in West Philadelphia in September 2006, built in partnership with the School District of Philadelphia and the surrounding community. According to Microsoft’s announcement on the day it opened, its first class of 170 freshmen was chosen by open lottery from the neighborhoods around it, and about 85 percent of those students came from low-income families.

The idea behind it was simple. What would a school look like if it were designed for the future, not only with technology built in, but with new ways to help students think differently about their careers and about what is expected of them?

One answer is set out on the first day. Students who enter the School of the Future are told that to graduate and receive a diploma, they have to apply to college. For a student in inner-city Philadelphia, Salcito says, that requirement is life-changing. It tells students from the start that higher education is part of their path, and it gives them a new level of confidence.

The project has since given rise to many hundreds of other innovative schools around the world, and the lesson Microsoft has drawn from them is the same. It is not about how thoughtfully a school uses technology, Salcito says. It is about how a school creates “a culture of expectation.”

In every great school, he argues, students walk in expecting more for their future. They arrive believing they can reach their dreams, and they raise those dreams to include what they can do for their community, their family and the wider world.

Is more technology in the classroom the answer?

When people look at the problems facing schools, the first answer is often more technology in the classroom. Salcito has seen a great deal of that over the last 30 years. Schools around the world, he says, have technology graveyards, or technology whose only effect has been to automate the old way of teaching.

Real change, in his view, starts somewhere else. It starts with celebrating and appreciating good teachers and with building new paths for teaching and learning. It also requires a different set of expectations for students. The economy and the workforce are changing every day, and schools have to ask how students are being prepared for them, and whether they are gaining the skills that new economy will demand.

That shift has to happen across the whole school, not one device at a time. It begins with what a classroom looks like, and with how the environment inside the school compares with the one outside it.

People learn differently, Salcito points out. They communicate, collaborate and think differently, and technology has changed how they find information and how the workforce operates. Yet for the most part, schools look much as they always have. Even schools that use technology often keep the same model of teaching and assessment that has been in place for hundreds of years. Schools already have the tools to think differently, he says. What has to change is how they use them.

Are education’s traditions holding back progress?

Salcito does not want to throw tradition out. Some of education’s traditions are good, and there is still real value in what happens inside schools. In Microsoft’s work with schools all over the world, the first step has always been the same: celebrate good school leaders and empower teachers. There are excellent teachers in the United States and around the world, he says, working hard every day to make their students’ lives better.

What schools have to do is ease the fear and tension that come with a move to technology. Many teachers worry that their role will be diminished once technology arrives in the classroom. Microsoft has found the opposite to be true. Technology asks more of teachers, not less, and it calls for more insight and more innovation in how they teach. Teachers can inspire students in a personal way that was never possible before, and they can build new ways of learning both in the classroom and outside it.

That second part is where technology changes the school day. Students can learn anywhere and at any time, so learning has to connect to life outside the school. Much of the curriculum, the reading and the coursework can be done outside school, offline or through online learning. That frees classroom time to be used differently.

Time in the classroom, Salcito says, should be special. It should be spent on planning, on building skills and on helping teachers guide each student along a personal path, and that takes good teaching. The task is to keep what is good inside schools, the teachers, the school leaders and in many cases the environment itself, and to apply technology to it carefully. When that happens, he expects much of the resistance schools see today to fade, and teachers and school leaders to come on board.

Is the world making progress in education?

Salcito travels to schools around the world, and his answer to whether progress is being made has two sides. He is optimistic that progress can be made. He is frustrated that it is not being made fast enough.

A generation of children, he argues, cannot be left to wait while adults debate one model after another. Schools cannot keep moving from one pilot to the next. They need to make bold changes, start thinking differently and commit to new approaches, in K-12 schools and beyond.

The potential, he says, is still enormous. Some of the smallest countries he visits have the largest ambitions for change, and he sees students challenging themselves and thinking about the impact they can make on the world.

He is excited about the students in classrooms today. They have opportunities ahead of them that earlier generations did not, with good tools and access to curriculum that was not available when he was in school, and he expects them to make a real impact on the world.

More conversations with founders and investors are collected in EdTech Entrepreneurs.

Anthony Salcito is vice president of worldwide education at Microsoft.

Subscribe to edCircuit to stay up to date on all of our shows, podcasts, news, and thought leadership articles.

More on EdTech Entrepreneurs

Share

More from edCircuit

Subscribe to edCircuit

Get the latest research, ideas, and stories delivered to your inbox.

Cancel