Closeup portrait of a female hand writing on a paper
A Model to Build Instructional Coaching Coherence Editor’s Note: This is Part Two of a Two-Part Series
by Howard Pitler, Ed.D.
To be most effective, coaching should be undertaken as a long-term process. A commonly used duration for a coaching cycle is one grading period. During each coaching cycle, the coach and coachee should begin by agreeing on a specific goal or goals to be accomplished. There should be a clear connection between the agreed-upon goal(s) and the school improvement plan and district strategic plan. Figure 2 is an example of a Coachee/Coach Goal Planning Template:
The initial planning process should identify not only the agreed-upon teacher learning goal for the coaching cycle but how to progress to the goal will be monitored. It is suggested that the coach and coachee work together to develop a rubric for the various components of the goal
The coach observes the lesson (or views a teacher-created video of the lesson) and takes notes based on the planning meeting.
Reflective Meeting
Reflective Meeting Plan
After the action plan is mutually developed between coach and coachee, a schedule of follow-up visits is developed to work the plan. An example of a follow-up schedules is below (Figure 3):
Everyone can benefit from having a coach. Professional sports teams have multiple coaches to help outstanding players reflect on their craft with the goal of becoming better. A good instructional coach can provide the same benefit for teachers. Just as a group of football coaches work under the head coach to move the team toward an agreed-upon goal, district instructional coaches will be most effective as a group if they have agreed-upon processes and procedures that move the district toward their goals. Coaching is specific to each individual coachee, but having a common set of procedures and protocols for all coaches will help the district move forward.
CUREE (2005) National Framework for Mentoring and Coaching, available here.
Author
Howard Pitler is a dynamic facilitator, speaker, and instructional coach with a proven record of success spanning four decades
Pitler is an ASCD Faculty member and the author of several ASCD publications including Classroom Instruction That Works, 2nd edition, Using Technology with Classroom Instruction That Works, and A Handbook for Classroom Instruction That Works, 2nd edition. Contact Pitler at hpitler@gmail.com or on his website.
Follow Howard on Twitter.
Further Reading
AI Literacy Day on March 27, 2026 highlights the growing importance of AI literacy in…
AI certification for educators is becoming a career differentiator, signaling the capacity to lead innovation…
This article highlights 10 reasons literacy gaps continue—and why real progress happens when strong programs…
The subscription creep problem in K–12 is growing. Districts are managing more recurring contracts than…
Every district and building needs a full-time Chemical Hygiene Officer (CHO). Without one, lab safety…
School safety first 5 minutes matter most. Learn how response, communication, and environment shape outcomes…