The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in schools is becoming increasingly prevalent. One in three U.S. teachers have used artificial intelligence tools in their teaching at least once, with English and social studies teachers leading the way, according to a RAND Corporation survey released in April 2024. A Walton Family Foundation survey conducted in May of 2024 showed that knowledge of and support for AI in education is growing among parents, students, and teachers. More than 80% of each group said AI has had – or will have – a positive impact on education.
The promise of AI is that it could positively transform teaching and learning by, for example, saving teachers time, providing personalized learning at scale, automating administrative tasks, enhancing student engagement, interpreting data, and more. However, before diving headfirst into the AI pool, school administrators should carefully evaluate a number of important factors.
Here is my list six important factors each school leader should ask before adopting AI resources for classroom use:
1. What are the Specific Educational Goals to Achieve with AI?
The first and foremost question administrators should consider is whether AI is the right tool to solve specific educational goals they aim to achieve through. AI can serve various purposes, from personalized learning and predictive analytics to automating administrative tasks and enhancing student engagement. Clarifying these goals should drive the selection of the right AI tools that align with the district’s vision and objectives.
For instance, if the primary goal is to provide personalized learning experiences, AI tools that adapt content to individual student’s learning needs would be ideal. Conversely, if the focus is on streamlining administrative processes, evaluating how AI tools can help provide insights to improve attendance might be more suitable.
2. How Will Data Privacy and Security be Managed?
Data privacy and security are paramount concerns when implementing AI in educational settings. AI tools often require access to vast amounts of student data, including academic records, personal information, and even behavioral patterns. Administrators must scrutinize who has access to this data and how itwill be collected, stored, and protected to prevent unauthorized access and breaches.
Key considerations include compliance with data protection laws such as FERPA (Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act), COPPA (Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act), GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation), and any state policies. Administrators should ask potential AI vendors about their data security measures, encryption protocols, inclusion of data in future foundational models and policies for data access and retention. Ensuring robust data privacy and security frameworks not only protects students but also builds trust among parents and the wider school community
3. What is the Level of User-Friendliness and Accessibility?
The success of AI implementation will depend on user-friendliness and accessibility. Administrators need to assess whether AI tools are intuitive and easy to use for both teachers and students. Complex or cumbersome tools and initiatives can lead to frustration and underutilization, negating the potential benefits of AI. Consider conducting pilot programs or trial runs to gather feedback from teachers and students on the usability of the AI tools. Administrators should ensure that there are comprehensive training programs in place to help teachers effectively integrate AI into their teaching practices.
4. What are the Ethical Implications and Bias Concerns?
AI systems are susceptible to biases present in the data on which they are trained. These biases could inadvertently lead to unfair treatment of certain student groups, perpetuating existing inequalities. Administrators must critically examine the ethical implications of deploying AI tools in their schools. Additionally, there is the risk of students and teachers becoming too reliant on AI tools to the point it erodes critical thinking skill development. Questions to address include: How traceable and transparent are the AI algorithms? Are there mechanisms in place to identify and mitigate biases? How can the District ensure fairness and equity in educational outcomes when using these AI-driven tools? Moreover, promoting awareness and understanding of AI ethics among educators and students is essential to foster a responsible and equitable AI implementation.
5. How to Ensure Transparency and Integrity?
While the technical intricacies of many AI systems may be challenging to grasp, it is essential for staff to attain AI literacy by understanding the fundamental principles of how AI operates and why it produces specific results. While large language modles (LLM) are making headlines around their ability to understand and generate text responses, there are other branches of AI such as machine learning that can be applied to opportunities like automated grading and content recommendations. AI products should clearly communicate not only their utility, but how they work. Engaging the community and stakeholders is crucial; maintaining transparency about the goals, benefits, and challenges of AI investments, and involving parents, students, and community members in the decision-making process, will build support and ensure the initiatives meet the community’s needs. The principles of honesty, trust, fairness, respect, and responsibility remain crucial for both students and staff.
6. How will AI Initiatives be Sustainable and Scaled?
Integrating AI in schools encompasses more than just the initial investment in software and hardware; it also entails ongoing costs such as maintenance, updates, training, and support. It is crucial to evaluate whether an investment is sustainable in the long term. Additionally, administrators must consider the scalability of AI tools, ensuring they can evolve and adapt to the school’s changing needs over time. Monitoring and evaluating the performance of AI tools through defined metrics and feedback mechanisms will allow for continuous improvement and data-driven decision-making. Thorough planning and strategic investment can maximize the benefits of AI, fostering an innovative and adaptable educational environment.
In addition, school districts need to create feedback loops that monitor the impact AI is having on the teaching experience and student outcomes to make sure the goals that were set out at the beginning of the implementation are accomplished. This is incredibly important to ensuring goals such as saving teachers time, spending more time with students, creating more personalized learning experiences, and improving student engagement are met.
Finally, there are a number of resources and organizations that administrators can consult for additional insight and guidance as they evaluate AI implementations. As a first step, it is worth seeing if the state has issued AI guidance. As of August 2024, 22 states have provided direction and advice to districts and schools on the use of AI, which have themes consistent with those described above. In addition, the US Department of Education has issued a couple of reports on AI, including Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Teaching and Learning: Insights and Recommendations. There are also a number of non-profit organizations working to constructively engage with AI in education, including TeachAI, AIEdu, ISTE, and EDSAFE AI.
Conclusion
The decision to integrate AI tools into schools must be approached with careful consideration and due diligence. By asking the right questions and thoroughly evaluating the implications, school administrators can make informed decisions that harness the power of AI while safeguarding the interests of their students and staff. The successful integration of AI in schools hinges on clearly answering the questions posed above. With these factors in mind, administrators can pave the way for a future where AI enhances the educational experience for all students, preparing them for a world where technology and learning go hand in hand.
Subscribe to edCircuit to stay up to date on all of our shows, podcasts, news, and thought leadership articles.