edcircuit
Science Safety - Safer Labs, Safer STEM, Safer CTE, Safer Arts, Safer Cyber
Promotional graphic with the text โ€œRegister Today for the EdTech Conference of the Year! www.CoSN.org/CoSN2026.โ€ Below is a skyline and Ferris wheel graphic with โ€œCoSN 2026.โ€ Blue gradient background.
Home CommunityAdvocates Philanthropy for Education: Behind the Smile
3 minutes read

Philanthropy for Education: Behind the Smile

When billionaires fund โ€œeducation reform,โ€ itโ€™s rarely about students โ€” itโ€™s about power, profit, and silencing teachers.

In David Greene's latest article, he discusses the wealthy, fake education reform philanthropists, including the Broad and Walton Foundations.

As John Oliver said, โ€œIf you want to do something evil, put it inside something boring.โ€

This is now true again in the case of the wealthy, fake education reform philanthropists, including the Broad and Walton Foundations behind TNTP (what used to be called The New Teacher Project), The Partnership for Education Justice, and Students for Education Reform.

Again, the very wealthy blame teachers for poverty caused issues in less successful schools. Broad is listed as the 65thย richest person in the world and the six Waltons on Forbesโ€™ list of wealthiest Americans have a net worth of $144.7 billion. This fiscal year three Waltonsโ€”Rob, Jim, and Alice (and the various entities that they control)โ€”will receive an estimated $3.1 billion in Wal-Mart dividends from theirย majority stakeย in the company.ย Meet the Family โ€“ The Walmart 1%

So behind what boring topic is their evil lurking? According to theย New York Times, They are behind the Minnesota challenge to teacher tenure laws.

โ€œOpening a new front in the assault on teacher tenure, a group of parents backed by wealthy philanthropists served notice to defendants on Wednesday in a lawsuit challenging Minnesotaโ€™s job protections for teachers, as well as the stateโ€™s rules governing which teachers are laid off as a result of budget cuts.โ€

This is an instant replay of the California and New York attempts to do the same thing: Break unions. As Brenda Cassellius, Minnesotaโ€™s commissioner of education said,

โ€œMinnesota has some of the most hard-working and talented teachers in the nation, and we are committed to ensuring every student has a dedicated and competent teacher.โ€ โ€œWe also have rigorous laws that protect due process for teachers and that, when followed, provide school administrators and school boards with the authority to remove teachers.โ€

Two years ago Iย co-wrote thisย with a local parent, Glen Dalgleish to ease peopleโ€™s minds about what Tenure is and isnโ€™t.

โ€œSince the Vergara ruling in California, there has been a lot of discussion about โ€œtenureโ€ but there has also been a lot of different interpretations what it actually means and unfortunately there has also been a lot of misinformation.

What Tenure is:

โ€œTenure is legal protection granted to some teachers that requires the school district to prove just cause before a termination. Tenure is obtained through a multi-year evaluation process of a teacher in a probationary track position and usually requires a vote of the governing body of the school. Once tenure is granted, a teacher is no longer considered an โ€œat-willโ€ employee (an employee that can be terminated for any reason at any time). Rather, to terminate an employee with tenure, a school district must show that it has โ€œjust causeโ€ to do so, typically at a hearing before an arbitrator.โ€

What Tenure is not:ย 

“Tenure is NOT a lifetime job guarantee. This is a key point to remember, as we believe this where a lot of the misinformation stems from. It is up to administrators, not boards, to make the right decision about tenure at this point. In NYS, they have 3 years to determine the quality of each of their new teachers.โ€

Why does this issue raising its ugly head? Ask John Oliverโ€ฆ

โ€œIf you want to do something evil, put it inside something boring.โ€

Subscribe to edCircuitย to stay up to date on all of our shows, podcasts, news, and thought leadership articles.

  • : Author

    David Greene is a former Social Studies teacher and coach. He is also a program consultant for an organization that helps high schools create and run experiential learning programs for seniors. In addition, he is the author of "Doing the Right Thing: A Teacher Speaks,โ€ is the former Treasurer of Save Our Schools and an active blogger and speaker. His blogs have appeared in Diane Ravitchโ€™s website, EdCircuit, Education Weekly, US News and World Report, and the Washington Post. David writes opinon pieces for EdCircuit. - The opinions he expresses here are solely his own.

    View all posts
Promotional graphic for the CoSN 2026 EdTech Conference featuring event details, a city skyline logo, and five professionally dressed people smiling against a blue gradient background.

Join Thousands of Other Subscribers

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Participate in the COmmunity

Square graphic with a purple background featuring CoSN Leading Education Innovation THE PODCAST above a microphone icon. Text below reads Produced in partnership with edCircuit. Thin green border outlines the image.
Banner for the CoSN 2026 Ed Tech Conference, reading โ€œBuilding Whatโ€™s Next, Together,โ€ April 13โ€“15 at Sheraton Grand Chicago Riverwalk. Includes a city skyline graphic and the website www.CoSN.org/CoSN2026.

Use EdCircuit as a Resource

Would you like to use an EdCircuit article as a resource. We encourage you to link back directly to the url of the article and give EdCircuit or the Author credit.

MORE FROM EDCIRCUIT

edCircuit emPowers the voices of education, with hundreds of  trusted contributors, change-makers and industry-leading innovators.

YOUTUBE CHANNEL

@edcircuit

Copyright ยฉ 2014-2025, edCircuit Media – emPowering the Voices of Education. ย 

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept

-
00:00
00:00
Update Required Flash plugin
-
00:00
00:00