Risk Management and Mitigation in the Science Lab

As a lab director, I’ve seen firsthand how a well-run science lab becomes the heartbeat of a school’s STEM program. In this environment, students are encouraged to explore, experiment, and engage with the world around them. But none of that matters without safety.

In middle and high school settings, students are still developing their understanding of risk, responsibility, and lab protocol. It’s our duty—not just as educators, but as caretakers of their potential—to create spaces where curiosity and caution go hand in hand.

This article explores what it truly means to manage risk in the school lab, from establishing a strong duty of care to implementing the Hierarchy of Controls, reinforcing the importance of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE), and most importantly, building a culture of safety that students carry with them long after the experiment ends.

Duty of Care: A Foundational Principle

At the heart of lab safety lies the legal and ethical principle of duty of care. Teachers, lab managers, administrators, and district leaders all share a responsibility to ensure that science labs are safe environments. This extends from choosing appropriate materials and procedures to maintaining lab equipment and ensuring students receive proper safety training.

In middle and high schools, this duty is even more pronounced. Students may lack the judgment, experience, or reflexes to instinctively avoid danger. Therefore, it’s up to adults to anticipate risks, implement protective measures, and foster a safety-first mindset that becomes second nature for young scientists.

The Hierarchy of Controls: A Systematic Approach to Lab Safety

Effective risk mitigation begins with understanding The Hierarchy of Controls—a six-step model that ranks safety strategies from most effective to least. By prioritizing controls that eliminate hazards altogether before relying on PPE or procedural changes, schools can create more robust, sustainable safety systems.

1. Elimination: Remove the Hazard Entirely

The most effective way to protect students is to remove the danger altogether. For example:

• Eliminate a volatile chemical from a lesson plan if a safer demonstration achieves the same learning goal.

• Replace flame-based reactions with digital simulations where appropriate.

In school labs, elimination might mean rethinking how lessons are structured or removing legacy equipment that no longer meets safety standards.

2. Substitution: Replace Hazardous Materials with Safer Alternatives

If a hazard cannot be eliminated, it should be replaced with a less dangerous option:

• Swap out a toxic solvent with a less harmful one.

• Use pre-prepared chemical kits instead of raw reagents.

Substitution ensures students still experience hands-on science without being exposed to unnecessary risk.

3. Engineering Controls: Isolate People from Hazards

Engineering controls focus on physical changes to the lab environment that isolate or contain hazards:

• Install fume hoods to vent dangerous vapors.

• Use splash guards and chemical storage cabinets.

• Implement shut-off mechanisms for gas or power lines.

These measures don’t rely on human behavior to be effective—making them essential for younger students who may not always follow procedures perfectly.

4. Isolation: Segregate Risky Processes or Equipment

In some safety frameworks, Isolation is treated as its own category; in others, it’s considered a specific form of engineering control. In the school lab context, it’s useful to treat Isolation as a deliberate strategy to separate hazards from students:

• Use locked cabinets for corrosive or flammable chemicals.

• Designate “hot zones” for heat-based experiments.

• Restrict access to certain tools or substances until safety training is complete.

Whether viewed as its own step or under engineering controls, Isolation is essential for reducing unintended exposure—especially with inexperienced learners.

5. Administrative Controls: Change the Way People Work

These controls involve creating rules, routines, and training to reduce exposure:

• Develop standard operating procedures (SOPs) for equipment and materials.

• Schedule regular safety drills and walkthroughs.

• Ensure all students pass a safety quiz before participating in experiments.

Clear signage, lab safety contracts, and ongoing education are critical components of administrative control—especially for students new to lab work.

6. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE): The Last Line of Defense

PPE is the most visible, but least reliable, form of protection because it depends on consistent use and proper fit:

• Safety goggles, gloves, aprons, and face shields are staples in the school lab.

• Respirators or chemical splash suits may be necessary in more advanced high school settings.

PPE should always be the backup—not the first or only line of defense. Still, schools must ensure that PPE is available, maintained, and worn correctly every time.

School Lab Safety Walkthrough: A 10-Point Checklist

Use this before each lab unit or major experiment to stay compliant, prepared, and proactive:

1. Are all hazardous materials properly labeled and stored?

2. Is PPE available, clean, and correctly sized for all students?

3. Have students received safety training for this specific activity?

4. Is there a clearly posted emergency plan and accessible exit path?

5. Are fire extinguishers, eyewash stations, and safety showers functional and accessible?

6. Are SDS (Safety Data Sheets) up to date and on file?

7. Are engineering controls like fume hoods, guards, and ventilation systems in place and functioning?

8. Are all incompatible chemicals stored separately to ensure isolation?

9. Are procedures for cleanup, disposal, and decontamination clearly defined and communicated?

10. Is the lab free of clutter and unnecessary equipment or chemicals for the day’s activities?

Creating a Culture of Safety in School Labs

Mitigating risk isn’t about checking boxes; it’s about building a culture where safety is second nature. Here are some steps schools can take:

• Regular Safety Audits: Conduct frequent inspections to ensure compliance and update protocols as needed.

• Professional Development: Train teachers and lab techs in current best practices, including emergency response and chemical hygiene.

• Student Ownership: Empower students by involving them in safety planning, signage creation, or peer training.

• Clear Reporting Systems: Establish simple, non-punitive methods for reporting accidents, near-misses, or unsafe conditions.

More Than a Checklist—It’s a Culture

Creating a safe science lab goes beyond protocols and PPE. It’s a commitment to teaching students that science is as much about precision and respect as it is about curiosity and discovery.

Every experiment should begin with a safety mindset.

Every piece of equipment, every chemical, and every lab procedure should reflect the principle that we protect what we value.

By embracing the hierarchy of controls, reinforcing duty of care, and building strong safety habits, we’re not just managing risk—we’re modeling responsibility, leadership, and the real-world practices of professional scientists.

Let’s create labs where safety is not an afterthought, but the first lesson we teach.

Subscribe to edCircuit to stay up to date on all of our shows, podcasts, news, and thought leadership articles.