Science Safety - Safer Labs, Safer STEM, Safer CTE, Safer Arts, Safer Cyber

Academic Discourse: 4 Key Aspects

Four strategies you can use to increase discourse in your classroom.

University students in a diverse classroom in discussion with their instructor

What academic discourse means in the classroom, four key aspects to build it, sentence starters, and the research on student talk.

When we think about traditional student talk and academic discourse, whether it is in response to a teacher’s question, discussion with other students or generating questions, there are common problems.

A list titled Problems with Student Talk in the Classroom includes controlled by teacher too little student talk too focused on answering teachers questions surface level not in depth and dominated by a few students

In recent years, the conversation has shifted from classroom talk and discussion to student discourse. What exactly is the difference? Student discourse is focused on “on-task” talk, as well as the use of academic vocabulary. In other words, not only is discourse more rigorous, it is more purposeful. There are four strategies you can use to increase discourse in your classroom.

Aspect One: Critical Thinking

Simple, low-level conversations should be, at best, a minor part of your classroom. Although there is a time and place for basic information, it should always lead to higher-level, critical thinking.

A table compares low and critical thinking tasks in English Social Studies Math and Science highlighting approaches from basic completion to analysis strategy selection and evaluation of solutions or topics

Aspect Two:  Reflection Encouragement

Reflection should be an ongoing part of discourse. Students should self-reflect, which then results in partner or group reflection. Students may need starter prompts to guide the reflective process.

A box titled Sample Reflection Prompts lists seven open ended questions including How did you decide What would happen if and What would you suggest for with blank spaces to fill in

Aspect Three:  Classroom Norms

If we want to incorporate discourse into our classroom, we cannot assume that it will automatically occur. In addition to teaching students what to discuss, we need to provide and teach a set of norms explaining how to discuss.

A list titled Sample Classroom Norms for Discourse outlining six guidelines for respectful inclusive and thoughtful classroom discussions including teamwork respect participation process focus and seeking help if needed

Aspect Four:  Student Participation

As we said earlier, a challenge you likely face is when a few students dominate discussions, whether it is in the whole class or in small groups or pairs. When you are guiding a whole class discussion, you can minimize this by calling on a variety of students, regardless of who raises their hands. You can also provide an opportunity to share with a partner before you ask for answers as a whole group, which encourages participation. In small groups, if you have issues with particular students and an individual conversation does not take care of the issue, you might consider using a timer or a timekeeper to limit the amount of time each student can speak or using tokens to be used for each comment. When a student runs out of tokens, they are no longer allowed to speak. Although neither of these is ideal, since they inhibit conversation, it may be necessary to ensure all students can participate. A related challenge to participation is when students get stuck or don’t know what to say, and therefore, they don’t say anything. In this case, we want to encourage students, which we can do by providing question starters. The goal is for other students to ask the starter questions so that the group can continue its discussion.

A chart titled Starter Questions lists prompts for deeper thinking justifying responses seeing others views and considering consequences with each bullet offering a different reflective question or statement

Adapted From:

https://ptgmedia.pearsoncmg.com/images/9780205627585/downloads/Echevarria_math_Ch1_TheAcademicLanguageofMathematics.pdf

 A Final Note

Academic discourse is a critical part of your classroom, but there are four key aspects to consider.  Critical thinking, reflection, norms, and participation facilitate discourse rather than simple conversation. 

  1. WNEP – Taking the Classroom Outdoors
  2. edCircuit – 3 Ways to Use Exit Slips in Your Classroom

Academic discourse: an edCircuit guide

Added by edCircuit in October 2026 to accompany the four aspects above.

What is academic discourse?

Academic discourse is the way people talk and write in academic settings: “communication with an academic audience for the purpose of furthering knowledge,” as Appalachian State University’s writing program puts it. In K–12 classrooms, it usually means student talk that is on task, uses the vocabulary of the subject, supports claims with evidence, and builds on what others have said.

Accountable Talk

One widely used framework, Accountable Talk, developed by Sarah Michaels, Mary Catherine O’Connor and Lauren Resnick at the University of Pittsburgh, holds classroom talk to three standards at once: accountability to the learning community, to accurate knowledge, and to rigorous thinking. It connects directly to the aspects above: norms build the learning community, and critical thinking and reflection build rigor.

Sentence starters students can use

  • “I agree with ___ because…”
  • “I respectfully disagree with ___ because…”
  • “How do you know that?”
  • “Can you say more about…?”
  • “Who can say that back in their own words?”
  • “The evidence that supports this is…”

What the research says

Structured classroom talk can improve learning. In an Education Endowment Foundation trial in England, Year 5 pupils in schools using a dialogic teaching program made the equivalent of two additional months’ progress in English and science and one in math. A study of 72 classrooms at the University of Cambridge found students did better when three features occurred together: building on others’ ideas, questioning them, and wide participation. An earlier meta-analysis found that many discussion approaches increased student talk and improved reading comprehension, though fewer improved critical thinking. These studies are several years old and mostly from upper elementary grades.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between classroom talk and academic discourse? Academic discourse is purposeful: students use subject vocabulary, give reasons and evidence, and respond to one another’s ideas.

How do I get every student talking? Use partner talk before whole-class discussion, call on a range of students, and give sentence starters, as described above.

Subscribe to edCircuit to stay up to date on all of our shows, podcasts, news, and thought leadership articles.

More on Teaching Strategies

  • Author and Educational Consultant

    Barbara R. Blackburn, Ph.D., a Top 30 Global Guru, is a best-selling author of more than 30 books, including the bestseller Rigor is NOT a Four-Letter Word, Rigor for Students with Special Needs, Seven Strategies for School Improvement and the Rigor in the Remote Classroom. An internationally recognized expert in the areas of rigor, motivation and leadership, she regularly collaborates with schools and districts for on-site and online professional development. Barbara can be reached through her website: www.barbarablackburnonline.com.

    View all posts
  • Educator and author

    Abbigail Armstrong, co-author of the upcoming books Rigor in the K-5 Math and Science Classroom and Rigor in the 6-12 Math and Science Classroom, has seen the challenges of impoverished children; she lived through it. She overcame early challenges to become a veteran public school teacher. She received her doctorate in Curriculum and Instruction from Gardner-Webb University in 2010. Building on her classroom experiences and specializations in math, content literacy, and middle level education, she became a professor at Winthrop University in 2005.

    She now teaches undergraduate courses in the Middle Level Education Program, and graduate courses in the Master of Arts in Teaching program, the Middle Level Education master's program, and in the Curriculum and Instruction specialty program. She supervises elementary and middle school student teachers, and collaborates with area schools on special projects. Dr. Armstrong has worked on several projects involving assessing rigor in schools and program evaluation. She also has a strong background in working with at-risk students, particularly those from a poverty background. She has worked with Dr. Blackburn for ten years, and is a skilled presenter who brings a real-life, down-to-earth perspective to her presentations. Participants are most excited about her practical approach and hands-on learning.

    View all posts
  • Middle School Language Arts Teacher

    Co-author of the upcoming books, Rigor in the K-5 Language Arts and Social Studies Classroom and Rigor in the 6-12 Language Arts and Social Studies Classroom, Melissa Miles is currently back in the classroom teaching middle school Language Arts. Previously, she was the Director of Educational Resources at a K-8 school in Charlotte, NC, where she served as supervisor to tutors, coordinator of resources for students with special needs, curriculum and pacing guide developer, and a resource leader for faculty. She has eighteen years of classroom teaching experience in grades 5-8.

    Melissa holds an undergraduate degree in Middle Level Education with a concentration in English and also holds a Master’s degree in Middle Level Education with a concentration in Language Arts. She is also credentialed as a National Board-Certified teacher for young adolescents, works as a SpringBoard Curriculum consultant to College Board, and is a certified member of the site visitation team for the “Schools to Watch” award. Melissa served as Dr. Blackburn’s editorial and research assistant for Classroom Motivation from A to Z, Classroom Instruction from A to Z, Literacy from A to Z, and Rigor is Not a Four-Letter Word. Her workshops are filled with humor, practical content, and a focus on student ownership of learning.

    View all posts
Share
Share Your Voice on edCircuit

More from edCircuit

Subscribe to edCircuit

Get the latest research, ideas, and stories delivered to your inbox.

Cancel