A Missing Puzzle Piece in STEM
A former Einstein Fellow at the Department of Energy argues that stories of real STEM professionals help students see themselves in STEM careers.

STEM career awareness can grow when middle schoolers meet real professionals, but studies are small. Here is what they show and how to apply it.
In 2017, Joshua Sneideman, who had served as the Albert Einstein Distinguished Educator at the US Department of Energy, argued that late elementary and middle school teachers should weave stories of STEM careers into the standards curriculum. Sneideman’s article appears below as published, followed by a section on what recent research says about STEM career awareness.
Integrate stories of STEM careers into the standards curriculum


If we could find meaningful ways to communicate the positive impact STEM professionals in EVERY industry are having on society, solving local and global problems, confronting the challenges of the 21st century, we could tap into the potential of this generation!

The National Research Council notes in their report, Successful K-12 STEM Education, 2011 indicates that for student interest in STEM to persist to workforce entry, it must be developed prior to leaving the 8th grade. The National Academies of Science in their report, Expanding Underrepresented Minority Participation: America’s Science And Technology Talent At The Crossroads (2011) recommend improving access and increase underrepresented minority student awareness of and motivation for STEM education and careers through improved information, counseling, and outreach. Taken in conjunction with the Girl Scouts’ report Generation STEM which indicates that STEM Girls as they call them, “have had significantly greater exposure to STEM fields.” In sum, the missing puzzle piece becomes abundantly clear.

STEM career awareness in middle school: what recent studies show and how teachers can build it
STEM career awareness is a student’s understanding of what people who work in science, technology, engineering and mathematics actually do, and whether that work could be for them. As Joshua Sneideman argues above, the people behind a scientific advance are often the most engaging part of the story, and students rarely meet them in a standards-based lesson. Studies published since 2017 give some support to this idea, though they are small and need careful reading.
A pilot study in grade 8
In July 2024, Aqsa Syeda and Gulnaz Zahid of the National University of Sciences and Technology in Pakistan published a pilot study in the European Journal of STEM Education. Thirty-three grade 8 students from two private schools in Islamabad, Pakistan, took a 12-lesson STEM career module of about 60 minutes per lesson, delivered after school. Students’ interest in STEM careers, their confidence that they could succeed in STEM (self-efficacy) and their knowledge of STEM careers all rose significantly between a test before and a test after the module. Four focus groups afterward found that students reported higher interest, knowledge and confidence.
One result deserves attention from teachers. Students’ confidence in math did not change significantly, even though their interest and general STEM confidence did. Learning what a data analyst or an engineer does can raise interest, but it appears not to settle a student’s doubts about math, which seem to need their own support.
The study has clear limits. The sample was small and not randomly chosen, the students came from two private schools in one city, and there was no comparison group, so the design cannot rule out other explanations for the gains. The authors themselves call it a pilot, and state that it lacked a control group. A close reading also found inconsistencies in the paper: the program length is given as two and a half weeks in one place and three weeks in another, and some values in its tables do not match their test statistics. Treat the numbers as a rough signal, and note that this section relies only on the paper’s main before-and-after results and its stated design.
Role models and intent to pursue STEM
A 2023 study by Duncan Davis-Hall, Laura Farrelly, Melissa Risteff and Chelsea Magin, in Biomedical Engineering Education, looked at middle school students who completed a series of challenges in the Couragion app built around scientific role models, including a biomedical engineer. Students rated their intent to pursue a STEM career before and after. Intent rose, including among students from underrepresented racial and ethnic groups and among girls, and students reported higher confidence, motivation and enjoyment. The NSF record page, which is the summary available here, does not report the number of students, does not mention a control group, and relies on student self-reports, so it shows promise rather than proof that the effect lasts. The study compared students from well-represented and underrepresented STEM backgrounds, and the page does not describe a control condition.
Taken together, the two studies point the same way as Sneideman’s argument: when middle schoolers learn about real people and real work, interest in STEM careers tends to rise in the short term. Neither shows that interest persists into high school or leads to a career choice, and neither used the kind of design that can show cause.
Where the jobs are changing
Sneideman’s own experience was in renewable energy and energy efficiency. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics projections for 2025 to 2035, released in August 2026, give a current picture of the labor market. Total employment is projected to grow 3.5 percent, slower than the 10.9 percent growth of 2015 to 2025. Within that, data scientists are projected to grow 34.6 percent, solar photovoltaic installers 36.5 percent and wind turbine service technicians 29.5 percent. Teachers can use these as examples of careers that connect to science and math standards but that students seldom hear about.
Bringing career stories into the standards curriculum
Sneideman’s recommendation is to integrate career stories into existing standards instead of adding a separate unit. A teacher can do this at modest cost. For a unit on energy, a short profile of a person who works in solar installation or energy efficiency can open the lesson and show where the unit’s concepts are used. A task at the end of a unit can ask students to find what a person in one occupation needs to know from that unit. A guest, in person or by video call, can answer student questions about a typical day.
Three cautions follow from the research. First, career exposure and math confidence are different goals, so a unit that builds career awareness should still teach math carefully and give students chances to succeed at it. Second, exposure works best when students see people they can identify with, so a teacher should vary the examples. Third, a school should not expect one lesson to change a student’s direction; the studies above used a series of lessons or repeated activities.
School leaders can support this by giving middle school teams a small shared collection of career profiles tied to the science and math standards they teach, and by building time for guest speakers into the calendar. Readers who want a broader view of how schools approach these subjects can turn to the edCircuit STEM education guide.
Further Reading
- Press of Atlantic City – Teentech introduces high school girls to STEM careers
- Jacksonville Free Press – Young Women of Color Conference Focuses on STEM Careers
- US News and World Report – Kelvin Beachum of the New York Jets Connects STEM and Sports
Related reading
More on STEM and STEAM Education



