Predicting a Shifting Higher Ed Landscape
Analyst Trace Urdan's 2017 view of higher education's shifts, checked against current enrollment data and the projected drop in graduates.

Higher education enrollment trends in 2026: total enrollment is up, yet private colleges lag and a graduate decline is projected.
Trace Urdan, an analyst of the education market, spoke in 2017 about falling enrollment, public-private partnerships and federal policy in higher education. A new section after the article checks Urdan’s points against the latest national enrollment data and the projected decline in high school graduates.
A noted analyst sees a seismic shift in how higher ed does business Hear more from Trace Urdan and other innovative analysts, thought leaders, and educators at the 2018 Future of Education Technology Conference (FETC), January 23-26 in Orlando, Florida. Learn more here.

When edCircuit spoke with Trace recently, one of the topics discussed at length was the dramatic changes occurring in higher education and the reaction from colleges and universities. Higher education institutions are suffering from a downward trending enrollment, and Trace says it is a combination of demographics and math. There are many paths and plans and solutions that colleges and universities are exploring and many possible solutions that they are choosing to adapt to survive.
“The number of 18-to-22-year-olds that are coming into the post-secondary system has flattened,” Trace said, “And those 18-to-22-year-olds have become much less affluent than that demographic has been historically. This is just a fact of life that colleges and universities have to live with.”
Trace also discussed how some struggling colleges are rethinking their brand and their offerings. Being broad-based learning institutions in the Harvard model, offering a wide variety of majors emphasizing comprehensive critical thinking, is no longer affordable to many schools outside the top elite. A rethinking is underway as to how to financially stay afloat while attracting potential students. As a consequence, institutions are beginning to narrow their focus on fixed areas of study to attract specific students with intensive learning environments that prepare them for good paying jobs when they graduate.
Private capital and innovation

“One of the things that intrigues me about looking at the private sector in education is the role that private capital plays specifically to spur innovation,” Urdan said. “The government is a pretty good consumer in the economy in a lot of respects, but what the government doesn’t do particularly well is invest in and put capital aside for innovation. That’s something that the private sector is quite good at.”
He saw heavy investment in early-stage education, ed tech and “last mile programs,” designed to fill “gaps right now between what formal education is accomplishing and what the working world expects.” Globally, “one of the most exciting areas is just how much post-secondary education is poised to grow in emerging economies,” from Latin America to the Middle East and Asia, “and I think ten years from now, we’ll be talking about the exploding post-secondary education systems and programs in Africa.”
Researchers, teachers and entrepreneurs

“There’s often a gap between what researchers are focused on, what practitioners are focused on, and what entrepreneurs are focused on,” Urdan said. Entrepreneurs build products without grounding in research or practice, “And then they find that the classroom teachers say, ‘Well, that’s a nice idea but here are the fifteen reasons why it doesn’t really make any sense on a practical basis.'” Younger, more digitally literate teachers are improving that dialogue. “It’s a messy process, to be sure, but I don’t feel like there are any large topics that aren’t getting tackled.”
Private companies can teach what schools lack time or money for. He pointed to EVERFI, which teaches digital literacy, financial literacy and drug and alcohol awareness, funded by corporations and foundations, “a great example of where the private market can find solutions to things that are sometimes problematic in the public sphere.”
A healthier kind of partnership

“I think there’s definitely more openness to public-private partnerships,” Urdan said, in K-12 and in higher education, where companies help with online courses, pathways for international students, retention and counseling. At the same time there is more skepticism after early failures, and “what we might be seeing now is a more skeptical and informed consumer in schools.” “You’re seeing an iteration that is a little bit healthier and more constructive than some of the past versions of this that we’ve seen.”
The federal role

Federal money is usually a single-digit share of a school’s budget, but “at the margin those dollars can be important,” which gives Washington “an out-sized influence,” Urdan said. In 2017 he saw “a much more laissez-faire approach” from the new administration, an effort “to try to push decision making down to states and localities,” following the reaction to the Common Core.
In higher education, “it’s been mostly trying to unwind things that the Obama administration put into place or simply rethink things,” including rules aimed at for-profit colleges and Title IX. “I think that this is a pendulum to some extent, and we’re seeing the pendulum swing back the other way.” Most proposed budget cuts had been removed in Congress, so “I don’t expect we’re going to see a big change” in federal education dollars.
Structural pressure on colleges

“There are enormous pressures on the current higher education system and they’re really structural,” Urdan said. “You have rising costs, and we’re reaching the upper limit of the consumers’ ability to come up with actual cash to pay for those costs.” States are spending less, and legislators, businesses and students want colleges “to do much more of the heavy lifting in terms of training students for employment.”
The result is consolidation. “There are some schools that won’t be able to make it. They just don’t have enough of an endowment, they don’t have enough natural demand… so you’re going to see schools close. You’re going to see schools merge.”
Not every college can be Harvard
The silver lining, he said, is that “schools are finally appreciating that they can’t all be sort of miniature clones of Harvard.” They are asking “What are we really good at? Which types of students do we serve well? Which types of students do we not serve well?”
Sweet Briar College, near closing, won a reprieve from alumni and then “dropped their prices. They narrowed their focus. They picked two or three things that they think really define their brand.” Urdan saw that kind of clarity as positive.

The same pressure pushes colleges to ask what to outsource and to build better online programs. “There’s a lot more careful attention and innovative thought being placed into building online programs and making them better.” Still, “there’s no question that it’s tough to be a college or a university, and it’s even tougher to be a non-elite college or university right now.”
Trace Urdan will be speaking at the upcoming Future of Education Conference (FETC) January 23-26 in Orlando, Florida.
Editor’s note (2026): This event has taken place.
Higher education enrollment trends in 2026: what the latest data show about the shift Trace Urdan described
In the article above, from a 2017 interview, analyst Trace Urdan said that colleges faced a flattening supply of 18-to-22-year-olds, rising costs and shrinking public support, and that some institutions would close or merge. Higher education enrollment trends since then have been more mixed than that forecast suggests. Total enrollment is rising again at the time of writing, while a long-projected drop in the number of high school graduates is about to begin. This section sets out what the most recent national data show, where the sources agree with Urdan, and where readers should be careful.
What fall 2025 enrollment looked like
The National Student Clearinghouse Research Center, which collects enrollment data from colleges across the country, published its final fall 2025 enrollment report on January 15, 2026. Total enrollment was more than 19.4 million, up 1.0 percent from 19.2 million in fall 2024. Undergraduate enrollment rose 1.2 percent to 16.2 million, and graduate enrollment fell 0.3 percent to 3.2 million.
The gains were not shared equally across types of institutions. Undergraduate enrollment rose 3.0 percent at community colleges and 1.4 percent at public four-year colleges, but fell 1.6 percent at private nonprofit four-year colleges and 2.0 percent at for-profit colleges. First-year enrollment was about 2.5 million, down 0.2 percent, with public four-year colleges gaining 18,000 first-year students and community colleges gaining 4,000. The Clearinghouse says institutions that report to it account for 97 percent of enrollments at degree-granting institutions eligible for federal student aid, and that its estimates are adjusted for coverage. The sector pattern fits Urdan’s remark that it is tougher for non-elite institutions, although the Clearinghouse figures do not measure selectivity, and a reader should treat them as one year of data and not a settled trend.
The projected decline in high school graduates
Urdan said the number of 18-to-22-year-olds entering post-secondary education had flattened. The best-known projection of what comes next is the Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education (WICHE) report Knocking at the College Door, whose 11th edition appeared in December 2024. WICHE projects that the number of high school graduates will peak in 2025, at roughly 3.9 million in its chart, and decline steadily through 2041, a fall of 13 percent from the peak that it attributes to fewer births 18 years earlier. Its executive summary adds that 38 states are projected to have fewer graduates in 2041 than in 2023, that only 10 states are projected to grow from the 2025 peak, and that the Midwest and Northeast have already begun to decline while the South is expected to grow before a slight decline at the end of the projections.
Two limits are worth stating. The WICHE projections are forecasts built on birth data and past patterns, and the racial and ethnic breakdowns use public school graduates only. WICHE also notes that the pandemic’s effect on future class size is small so far, with about 750,000 fewer graduates projected through 2037 than in the 2020 edition, and that the larger effect may come from learning loss, which the data cannot yet measure. The fall 2025 enrollment gains and the projected fall in graduates are therefore not necessarily in conflict, because the projected decline in graduates is only starting.
Closures and consolidation
Urdan predicted that some colleges without large endowments or natural demand would close or merge, and Urdan gave Sweet Briar College as an example of a school that narrowed its focus and cut its prices. BestColleges runs a tracker of public and private nonprofit college closures and mergers, which was last updated on April 16, 2026. It counts at least 49 colleges or campuses that have closed or announced closures since March 2020, and at least 40 that have merged or announced mergers, and it lists at least 12 public or nonprofit colleges that merged or closed in 2025. The tracker excludes for-profit schools and counts announced events as well as completed ones, and the totals change as it is updated, so a reader should check the current page. Enrollment totals say nothing about which institutions are under financial strain.
What this means for families and campus leaders
- Families choosing a college can ask about enrollment and finances at the specific institution, as the national totals hide the difference between sectors.
- Community colleges and public four-year colleges grew in fall 2025 while private nonprofit and for-profit colleges did not, so leaders at private colleges may want to weigh the narrower focus Urdan describes.
- Leaders planning beyond 2026 should use the WICHE state-by-state projections for their own region, because a national decline of 13 percent and a state decline of 30 percent are very different planning problems.
- Online and partnership programs, which Urdan expected to grow, should be judged on the same evidence of student outcomes as any other program.
For more, see edCircuit’s higher education coverage.
Further Reading
- The Atlantic – The Rural Higher-Education Crisis
- The Sacramento Bee – This local college program connects students with $18-an-hour jobs in little time
- edCircuit – EVERFI Supports the 14th National Prescription Drug Take Back Day
Related reading
More on Higher Education



